Understanding Private Mortgage Insurance (PMI): What It Is, How to Avoid It, and How to Remove It

Understanding Private Mortgage Insurance

Conventional PMI cancels automatically when your loan balance reaches 78% of the original purchase price and can be requested at 80%; depending on your down payment, that typically takes 3 to 11 years. Monthly cost runs $50 to $400 on a $300,000 loan depending on credit score and down payment. On FHA loans with less than 10% down, mortgage insurance never cancels without refinancing into a conventional loan. PMI protects the lender against default losses, not the borrower.

This guide covers what PMI costs, when it applies, every legitimate way to avoid it, and exactly how to get it removed.

What Is PMI and Why Does It Exist?

Private Mortgage Insurance is a policy the lender requires when a borrower’s down payment is below 20% on a conventional loan. The lender buys the policy; the borrower pays the premium. If the borrower defaults and the home forecloses for less than the outstanding loan balance, the PMI policy compensates the lender for the loss.

The logic is straightforward: a borrower with less than 20% equity has more incentive to walk away in a declining market than one who has a larger financial stake. PMI offsets that risk, which is why lenders are willing to approve loans with smaller down payments at all.

PMI is issued by private mortgage insurance companies such as MGIC, Radian, Essent, National MI, and Arch MI. Rates vary by insurer, and lenders often have preferred relationships with specific providers. The borrower has no say in which insurer is used.

PMI vs. MIP: Conventional vs. FHA Mortgage Insurance

PMI and MIP (Mortgage Insurance Premium) are both forms of mortgage insurance, but they work differently, and the distinction has significant financial consequences.

FHA MIP rates cited reflect HUD Mortgagee Letter 2023-05, which reduced the annual MIP rate for most 30-year loans to 0.55% effective March 20, 2023 (hud.gov/program_offices/housing/sfh/handbook_4000-1). VA funding fee rates reflect the VA’s current schedule published at va.gov/housing-assistance/home-loans/funding-fee-and-closing-costs/. USDA annual guarantee fee rates are published by USDA Rural Development at rd.usda.gov/programs-services/single-family-housing-programs.

The most important difference: FHA MIP with less than 10% down lasts for the life of the loan. There is no automatic cancellation threshold. The only way to eliminate FHA MIP once it’s been locked in is to refinance into a conventional loan with at least 20% equity.

For a borrower putting 3.5% down on a $300,000 FHA loan, the monthly MIP runs approximately $138. Over 10 years, that’s $16,560. Over 20 years, $33,120. None of it ever cancels without a refinance.

This is one of the most important arguments for choosing conventional over FHA when the borrower’s credit score qualifies for competitive conventional pricing.

How Much Does PMI Cost and How Does Credit Score Play a Role?

PMI rates are primarily driven by two factors: the loan-to-value ratio (how much you’re borrowing relative to the home’s value) and the borrower’s credit score. A higher credit score at the same LTV produces a meaningfully lower PMI rate.

Approximate annual PMI rates by credit score (at 5% down / 95% LTV):

These are general ranges. Actual rates vary by insurer, lender, loan term, and specific LTV within the range. At 10% down (90% LTV), rates are lower than at 5% down across all credit score tiers.

What this means in practice: A borrower with a 760 credit score putting 5% down might pay $50/month in PMI. A borrower with a 660 score putting 5% down on the same loan might pay $270/month. The difference, $2,640 per year, is one of the clearest illustrations of why improving your credit score before applying has direct dollar value.

These are general ranges drawn from published rate schedules from major PMI providers including MGIC (mgic.com) and Radian (radian.com). The Urban Institute’s Housing Finance Policy Center (urban.org/housing) publishes periodic analysis of mortgage insurance market pricing that provides additional context on how rates have shifted over time. Actual rates vary by insurer, lender, loan term, and specific LTV; the most accurate estimate for a specific borrower comes from running an actual credit profile against current insurer pricing through a loan officer.

When Is Paying PMI Required?

PMI is required specifically on conventional loans when the loan-to-value ratio exceeds 80% at closing. The three situations where this applies:

1. Down payment below 20%. The most common scenario. A buyer purchasing a $350,000 home with 5% down ($17,500) is borrowing $332,500, which is 95% LTV. PMI applies until the balance reaches 80% of the original purchase price ($280,000).

2. Refinance with less than 20% equity. A homeowner refinancing with less than 20% equity in the home will need PMI on the new conventional loan. This is one reason some homeowners wait to refinance until they’ve built sufficient equity.

3. Cash-out refinance exceeding 80% LTV. A cash-out refinance that pushes the new loan above 80% of the home’s value will require PMI on the new loan.

Loan programs that do not require PMI:

VA loans have no PMI at any down payment level. This is one of the VA loan benefits’ most financially significant features, particularly over a long holding period.

USDA loans have no PMI either, but charge an annual guarantee fee of 0.35%, which functions similarly. This is substantially lower than FHA MIP.

FHA loans have MIP rather than PMI, which operates under different rules as described above.

How PMI Affects Your Monthly Payment and DTI

PMI is included in your total monthly housing payment for debt-to-income ratio purposes. Lenders add the estimated monthly PMI premium to principal, interest, taxes, and insurance (PITI) when calculating your front-end and back-end DTI ratios.

Example:

A buyer qualifies for a $300,000 conventional loan at 6.75% with 5% down. Their gross monthly income is $7,000.

Without PMI in the calculation, the front-end DTI would show 34.5%. The difference matters at the margins, where a buyer whose income barely supports the loan might find the PMI addition pushes their DTI above the lender’s threshold.

This is one reason some buyers choose lender-paid PMI or a piggyback loan structure: removing the monthly PMI line item from the payment can improve qualification ratios.

How to Avoid PMI

Five approaches can eliminate or replace PMI, ranging from the straightforward (larger down payment) to the program-specific (VA loans) to the structural (piggyback loans and lender-paid PMI). The right option depends on your down payment, credit score, VA eligibility, and how long you plan to stay in the home.

Put 20% Down

The simplest approach: a down payment of 20% or more on a conventional loan eliminates PMI entirely from the beginning. On a $350,000 home, 20% is $70,000.

This is the only approach that avoids PMI at inception without adding cost elsewhere (higher rate, second mortgage, or higher loan balance). The trade-off is the capital requirement.

Use a VA Loan (The Best Option for Eligible Borrowers)

VA loans carry no mortgage insurance at any down payment level, including zero down. For eligible veterans, active-duty service members, and qualifying surviving spouses, the VA loan eliminates PMI permanently, not just through a threshold or a workaround.

The VA charges a one-time funding fee (2.15% for first use with 0% down in 2026) that can be financed into the loan. For a veteran who is exempt from the funding fee due to service-connected disability, even this cost is eliminated.

Comparing VA to conventional with PMI over time: a veteran who chooses VA at 0% down versus conventional at 5% down avoids $150–$200/month in PMI, avoids the down payment entirely, and typically receives a competitive or lower interest rate. Over 10 years, the PMI savings alone often exceed the one-time funding fee.

USDA Loans (No PMI, Lower Annual Fee)

USDA Rural Housing loans charge a 0.35% annual guarantee fee rather than PMI. On a $250,000 loan, this runs approximately $73/month, which is significantly lower than conventional PMI at the same credit score tier and well below FHA MIP.

Combined with zero down payment and competitive rates, USDA is financially superior to FHA for buyers who meet the geographic eligibility and income limit requirements.

Piggyback Loan (80/10/10 Structure)

A piggyback loan uses a second mortgage to bring the first mortgage to exactly 80% LTV, eliminating the PMI requirement on the first loan. The classic structure:

• First mortgage: 80% of the purchase price
• Second mortgage (HELOC or fixed second): 10% of the purchase price
• Down payment: 10%

On a $300,000 home, this means a $240,000 first mortgage (no PMI), a $30,000 second mortgage, and a $30,000 down payment.

The trade-off: The second mortgage typically carries a higher interest rate than the first (often prime plus a margin), and it adds a second monthly payment. The question is whether the combined cost of the second mortgage loan is lower than what PMI would have cost.

At higher credit scores where PMI rates are low, the piggyback structure may cost more than PMI would. At lower credit scores where PMI rates are high, it may save money. Run the numbers for your specific credit profile before assuming the piggyback is the better option.

Some lenders also offer 80/15/5 structures (15% second, 5% down), though these are less common.

Lender-Paid PMI (LPMI)

With lender-paid PMI, the lender pays the PMI premium upfront in exchange for a slightly higher interest rate. The borrower has no monthly PMI line item, but pays a higher rate for the life of the loan.

The key trade-off: The higher rate is permanent. If conventional PMI would have cancelled at 80% LTV in 4–5 years, LPMI could cost more in total over a longer holding period. If the borrower plans to sell or refinance before PMI would have cancelled, LPMI can be the better option.

LPMI also simplifies the monthly mortgage payment calculation and removes the PMI line item from DTI, which can help qualification at the margins.

When LPMI makes sense:

• Short expected holding period (3–5 years or less)
• Borrower expects to refinance before reaching 80% LTV
• Marginal DTI situation where removing the PMI payment aids qualification
• High credit score borrower where the rate premium is small

When LPMI does not make sense:

• Long expected holding period (10+ years)
• Borrower will reach 80% LTV quickly through appreciation or extra payments
• The rate premium significantly exceeds what PMI would have cost

How to Remove PMI From a Conventional Loan

The Homeowners Protection Act of 1998 (HPA) establishes federal rules governing PMI cancellation on conventional loans closed on or after July 29, 1999.

Automatic Cancellation at 78% LTV

Lenders are required by law to automatically cancel PMI when the loan balance reaches 78% of the original purchase price, based on the scheduled amortization. The borrower does not need to request this: it is a legal requirement.

At 78% LTV based on scheduled payments, the lender must cancel PMI on the date the principal balance is scheduled to reach that threshold, as long as the borrower is current on payments.

Important: This 78% is calculated based on the original purchase price (or appraised value at closing, whichever was lower), not the current market value of the home. A home that has appreciated significantly may have a much lower actual LTV, but automatic cancellation under HPA is triggered by the amortization schedule against the original price.

Requesting Cancellation at 80% LTV

Borrowers have the right to request PMI cancellation in writing when the loan balance reaches 80% of the original value, as long as:

• The request is in writing
• The borrower has a good payment history (no 30-day lates in the past 12 months; no 60-day lates in the past 24 months)
• The lender does not have evidence that the property value has declined below the original value
• The borrower can certify, if required, that no subordinate liens exist on the property

At 80% LTV based on the original value, the borrower must proactively request cancellation. The lender will not automatically cancel at 80%; automatic cancellation under HPA occurs at 78%.

To calculate when you’ll hit 80% LTV: Take your original purchase price, multiply by 0.80, and compare to your current loan balance. If your loan balance is at or below that figure, you may be eligible to request PMI cancellation now.

Using a New Appraisal to Accelerate PMI Removal

For homeowners who have seen significant appreciation, a new appraisal may establish a current value high enough to prove equity above 20% even if the scheduled amortization hasn’t reached that point yet.

This is a more flexible approach than waiting for scheduled payments to reach 80% based on the original price, but it comes with conditions:

• The loan must typically be at least 2 years old to request PMI cancellation based on current value (some lenders allow at 12 months with significant appreciation)
• At 2 years, most lenders require the current LTV to be at or below 75% based on the new appraisal
• At 5 years, most lenders accept 80% LTV based on the new appraisal
• The appraisal must be ordered through the lender using an approved appraiser (borrowers cannot submit their own appraiser)
• A fee (typically $400–$700) applies

If your home has appreciated meaningfully since purchase, this is often the fastest path to PMI elimination short of refinancing.

Refinancing to Remove FHA MIP

For FHA borrowers with less than 10% down, refinancing into a conventional loan is the only way to eliminate mortgage insurance before paying off the loan entirely.

The conventional loan will require the borrower to have at least 20% equity at the time of refinancing to avoid PMI on the new loan. This equity can come from:

• Accumulated principal payments
• Home appreciation since the original purchase
• A combination of both

The calculation: if the home has appreciated and the borrower has paid down some principal such that the current loan balance is at or below 80% of the current appraised value, a rate-and-term refinance into conventional eliminates MIP entirely.

Refinance decision factors:

• Does the new conventional rate plus no MIP produce a lower monthly payment than the existing FHA rate plus MIP?
• How long will it take to recover the closing costs of the refinance through monthly savings?
• Is there sufficient equity (20%) to avoid PMI on the new conventional loan?

At many credit score tiers, once an FHA borrower has reached 20% equity, the monthly savings from eliminating MIP through a conventional refinance are substantial.

The Homeowners Protection Act: Your Legal Rights

The Homeowners Protection Act (HPA) of 1998, Public Law 105-216, codified at 12 U.S.C. §§ 4901–4910, establishes specific legal protections for borrowers on conventional loans. The full text is available at law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/12/4901. Key requirements include the following:

• Lenders must provide written disclosure at closing of the estimated date automatic PMI cancellation will occur
• Lenders must notify borrowers annually of their right to request PMI cancellation
• Automatic PMI cancellation is required at 78% LTV based on original value, with no required request from the borrower
• Lenders who fail to cancel PMI at the legally required time may be liable for damages

These protections apply to conventional loans. FHA MIP is governed by different rules (HUD regulations) and does not fall under the HPA.

If a lender fails to cancel PMI after receiving a valid written request and the borrower meets all eligibility requirements, the borrower can file a complaint with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) at consumerfinance.gov/complaint.

PMI vs. Other Costs: A Real-Money Comparison

Homebuyers sometimes resist making a down payment larger than the minimum to avoid PMI, arguing they’d rather keep the cash. The break-even analysis makes the comparison concrete.

Scenario: $350,000 purchase. Buyer has enough saved for 20% down ($70,000) but is considering 5% down ($17,500) instead.

The buyer who puts 5% down retains $52,500 in cash. At the 5% down path, they pay $342/month more. How long does the retained cash need to be invested to produce $342/month in returns?

$52,500 generating $342/month requires a monthly return of 0.65%, or approximately 7.8% annualized. That’s a return available from equities but not guaranteed and not risk-free. Meanwhile, the PMI cost is certain and not deductible for most borrowers.

For buyers who have the 20% and are weighing investment returns against guaranteed PMI elimination, the break-even is not as favorable for the PMI path as it first appears. For buyers who simply don’t have 20%, the analysis is different: the relevant question is whether a lower-PMI option (VA, USDA, or higher credit score) changes the math.

Frequently Asked Questions About PMI

PMI deductibility has varied over the years and has not been permanent. Congress has periodically extended a deduction for qualifying borrowers, but it has lapsed and been reinstated multiple times. As of 2026, consult a tax advisor for the current status. Do not assume deductibility when planning PMI costs.

Does PMI protect me if I can’t make my payments?

No. PMI protects the lender, not the borrower. If you default and the home forecloses for less than the outstanding balance, the PMI insurer compensates the lender. Your credit is still damaged, and you still lose the home. PMI provides you no direct financial protection or assistance if you fall behind.

Can I choose my PMI company?

No. The lender selects the PMI provider. Borrowers have no choice in which insurer covers their loan. This is one reason rates vary between lenders on otherwise identical loan scenarios: different lenders have different PMI provider relationships and pricing arrangements.

Does PMI ever go away on an FHA loan?

Only through refinancing into a conventional loan or by putting 10% or more down at origination, in which case MIP ends after 11 years. For FHA loans with less than 10% down, MIP lasts for the life of the loan without refinancing.

How do I know when my PMI will automatically cancel?

Your lender is required by the Homeowners Protection Act to provide this date in writing at closing. It is typically disclosed on your Loan Estimate and Closing Disclosure. You can also calculate it yourself: multiply the original purchase price by 0.78, and when your loan balance reaches that number based on your amortization schedule, PMI must be cancelled.

Can my lender refuse to cancel PMI when I request it?

A lender can deny a PMI cancellation request if the borrower does not meet the requirements: the property value has declined, there are subordinate liens, or the payment history has delinquencies. If all requirements are met and the lender still refuses, you have recourse through the CFPB complaint process.

Does a higher down payment always eliminate PMI?

On conventional loans, any down payment of 20% or more eliminates PMI at origination. Down payments of 10–19.99% require PMI on conventional loans until the balance reaches 78% LTV based on the original price. On FHA loans, MIP applies regardless of down payment; 10% or more only changes the MIP duration (11 years vs. life of loan).

Is PMI the same as homeowners insurance?

No. PMI covers the lender against default losses. Homeowners insurance covers the borrower’s property against damage, theft, liability, and other covered perils. Both may be escrowed and collected monthly, but they are separate policies serving completely different purposes.

Can I avoid PMI with a co-borrower?

Adding a co-borrower does not eliminate the PMI requirement on its own. PMI is triggered by LTV, not by the number of borrowers. A co-borrower’s income and credit affect qualification but do not change the down payment percentage or LTV calculation.

What happens to PMI if I refinance?

A refinance effectively creates a new loan. If the new loan has an LTV at or below 80% based on the new appraisal, no PMI is required on the conventional loan. If the LTV exceeds 80% after refinancing, PMI applies to the new loan at the new loan’s terms and PMI rates. FHA loans refinanced into conventional at 80% or below LTV eliminate MIP on the new loan.

Is it better to put 20% down or pay PMI?

It depends on what you would do with the retained cash and how quickly you would reach 80% LTV. The break-even math generally favors putting 20% down when the alternative is leaving the retained cash in a low-yield savings account, since PMI is a certain monthly cost while savings account returns are modest. The math shifts when the retained cash would be invested in assets producing returns above the effective PMI cost rate.

At a 760+ credit score where PMI runs $50–$90/month on a $300,000 loan, the monthly cost of carrying PMI is low enough that the flexibility of retaining more cash may outweigh the PMI expense, particularly if the borrower expects to reach 80% LTV within 3–5 years through appreciation or extra payments. At a 660 credit score where PMI runs $250–$300/month on the same loan, the calculus shifts significantly toward putting more down to reduce or eliminate the PMI exposure.

A practical rule: if you have exactly 20% saved and putting it all down leaves you with no emergency fund or cash reserves, the flexibility of a smaller down payment (and therefore retained reserves) may justify the PMI cost. A borrower who closes with no reserves is in a more vulnerable financial position than one who pays PMI while maintaining 3–6 months of expenses in savings.

How much is PMI on a $300,000 or $400,000 loan?

PMI costs vary by credit score and down payment. These are approximate monthly ranges for a 5% down, 30-year conventional loan:

On a $300,000 loan (borrowing $285,000):

On a $400,000 loan (borrowing $380,000):

These figures are approximate ranges based on published rate schedules from major PMI providers, including MGIC (mgic.com/rates) and Radian (radian.com). Actual rates vary by lender, specific LTV within a tier, loan term, and property type. The most accurate PMI estimate for your specific scenario comes from a loan officer who can run your actual credit profile against current insurer pricing.

How long do you have to pay PMI?

On a conventional loan, PMI lasts until your loan balance reaches 78% of the original purchase price based on the scheduled amortization, at which point it cancels automatically under the Homeowners Protection Act (12 U.S.C. §§ 4901–4910). You can request cancellation in writing at 80% LTV.

How long that takes depends on your down payment and whether you make extra principal payments or benefit from home appreciation:

• 5% down, no extra payments, no appreciation: Approximately 9–11 years on a 30-year loan at typical amortization
• 10% down, no extra payments: Approximately 5–7 years
• 15% down: Approximately 2–3 years
• With significant appreciation: Potentially 1–2 years if a new appraisal establishes current LTV at or below 75–80%

On FHA loans with less than 10% down, MIP lasts for the life of the loan with no cancellation threshold. The only way to remove it is to refinance into a conventional loan once you have sufficient equity. This distinction is the primary financial reason to prefer conventional over FHA when your credit score qualifies for competitive conventional pricing.

What factors influence the cost of PMI?

Six factors determine where your PMI rate falls within the ranges lenders price:

Credit score is the largest single factor. The difference between a 760+ score and a 640 score can produce a PMI rate three to four times higher on the same loan, representing hundreds of dollars per month. Improving your credit score before applying is the single highest-return action for reducing PMI cost.

Loan-to-value ratio is the second major factor. A 10% down payment (90% LTV) produces a lower PMI rate than 5% down (95% LTV) at every credit score tier. Even moving from 5% to 10% down can reduce the PMI rate meaningfully.

Loan term affects pricing. Fifteen-year loans typically carry lower PMI rates than 30-year loans at the same LTV, because the shorter term means faster equity accumulation and lower default risk over time.

Fixed vs. adjustable rate influences PMI pricing. Adjustable-rate mortgages sometimes carry higher PMI rates than fixed-rate loans because of the payment uncertainty associated with future rate adjustments.

Property type matters. Single-family owner-occupied homes receive the most favorable PMI rates. Condominiums and second homes may carry slightly higher rates depending on the insurer.

Occupancy type is significant. Owner-occupied primary residences receive the lowest PMI rates. Non-owner-occupied investment properties, if eligible for conventional financing, carry substantially higher PMI rates.

Is PMI tax-deductible?

The answer has changed multiple times and is not permanently settled. Congress first made PMI premiums deductible for qualifying borrowers in 2007 under the Tax Relief and Health Care Act. Since then, the deduction has lapsed and been retroactively extended several times as part of broader tax extender legislation rather than being made a permanent feature of the tax code.

When the deduction has been active, it applied to borrowers whose adjusted gross income (AGI) fell below specific thresholds, with the deduction phasing out for higher-income filers. It was treated as an itemized deduction on Schedule A, meaning borrowers who take the standard deduction received no benefit from it regardless of how much PMI they paid.

The deduction is not guaranteed to be available in any given tax year, and it is not something to factor into your PMI cost analysis as a reliable offset. A borrower who assumes the deduction will be available and prices their monthly budget accordingly may find the deduction has lapsed for the tax year in question.

For current-year status, the IRS publication on mortgage interest deductions (irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p936.pdf) is the authoritative source. A tax advisor can confirm whether the deduction is active for the year you are filing and whether your income level qualifies. Do not assume deductibility is available when planning PMI costs; treat it as a potential benefit that may or may not materialize rather than a certainty.

Summing Up Types of Mortgage Insurance Costs, and How Much You Have to Pay for PMI

PMI is one of the most consistent recurring costs in residential mortgage financing, and understanding it precisely changes both the pre-purchase decisions (which loan type, which down payment, which program) and the post-purchase strategy (when to request cancellation, when refinancing makes sense).

The core points to carry:

Conventional PMI cancels at 78% LTV automatically and can be requested at 80%. FHA MIP with less than 10% down does not cancel without refinancing. VA loans have no mortgage insurance at any level. USDA has a lower annual fee in place of PMI. PMI costs are significantly affected by credit score, improving your credit score is one of the highest-ROI financial preparations that you can do before a mortgage application.

For most buyers who don’t have 20% down and don’t have VA eligibility, the choice is between accepting conventional PMI with the knowledge it will eventually cancel, or paying the FHA upfront MIP plus lifetime monthly MIP with no automatic cancellation threshold.

Understanding Private Mortgage Insurance

About the author: This article was written by Luke Skar of MadisonMortgageGuys.com. As the Social Media Strategist, his role is to provide original content for all of their social media profiles as well as generate new leads from his website.

We provide award-winning customer service to clients who need to purchase a home or refinance an existing mortgage.